Inteligencia y Seguridad Frente Externo En Profundidad Economia y Finanzas Transparencia
  En Parrilla Medio Ambiente Sociedad High Tech Contacto
Frente Externo  
 
23/03/2010 | Mexico's Brazil Envy - Hoping History is not Destiny

David Agren

Earlier this year, Mexican President Felipe Calderón admonished a meeting of the nation's top diplomats, urging them to speak better of Mexico in order to counter negative perceptions of the country generated by its ongoing war on drug cartels and the 2009 outbreak of the H1N1 virus.

 

Calderón raised eyebrows, however, when, to emphasize his point, he mentioned Brazil, saying the emerging South American power is perceived abroad in far more favorable terms than Mexico, in part because its own citizens speak well of it.

"I have never as a politician nor as president . . . heard a Brazilian speak badly of Brazil. And, yet, I've heard many Mexicans speak badly of Mexico to the world," he said. "The international perception is that Mexico is in chaos . . . and Brazil is some sort of paradise."

The comments were perhaps a reflection of Calderón's frustrations with his own country, where a three-year crackdown on drug-trafficking cartels has claimed more than 18,000 lives, the economy has lagged (dropping 6.8 percent in 2009), foreign direct investment has been halved over the past year, and his agenda for state, labor and economic reforms were dealt a blow in last July's midterm elections.

But the comments reflected a sentiment often heard in Mexico -- Brazil envy.

While Mexico suffered through a miserable 2009, Brazil emerged from the global economic downturn more quickly. It also continued wielding increased regional influence with its peacekeeping presence in Haiti and involvement in the Honduras political crisis, at a time when Mexico was busy mending fences with other countries in Latin America, such as Venezuela and Cuba.

That Brazil was awarded the 2016 Olympics was another point of envy for some in Mexico, including First Lady Margarita Zavala. In February, Zavala noted that there are 10 homicides for every 100,000 inhabitants in Mexico. "In Brazil," she went on, "there are 25 homicides for every 100,000 inhabitants. We have less than half [the homicide rate] of Río de Janeiro . . . and they won the Olympics and [the 2014] World Cup."

Ironically, in September, the Mexico Football Federation withdrew its early bids for the 2018 and 2022 World Cups due to funding issues.

"The average Mexican is happy for Brazil's success, but for the elites, there's some jealousy," said Mexico City pollster Dan Lund, president of the Mund Group.

And sometimes, along with that jealousy comes fear.

Mexico and Brazil have started exploring a free-trade agreement that some in Mexico have promoted as a way of lessening the country's dependence on United States -- the destination for some 80 percent of Mexican exports.

But a 2009 poll released by a major business group found that 95 percent of Mexican industry trade groups were uneasy about such a deal. This, even though Mexican companies such as telecommunication giants Telmex Internacional and América Movil -- both controlled by the world's richest man, Carlos Slim Helú -- have performed strongly in the Brazilian market.

Much of Mexico's dependence on the U.S. market is attributed to geography, but also to the 1994 NAFTA agreement.

The history and timing of NAFTA's adoption now seems ironic for some political observers, given the current Brazil-envy on display.

"While Brazil was consumed by a deep crisis [in the early 1990s], Mexico sold itself as the best emerging market on the planet," political analyst Juan E. Pardinas wrote last fall in the Mexico City newspaper, Reforma. "For us, the future was a sweet promise; for them, a black cloud. Today, our respective national futures are no longer what they were before."

Pardinas and other observers attribute the turnaround to economic reforms in Brazil and pragmatic governance. Over that same time period, Mexico has been mired in political gridlock -- especially since 1997, when the lower house of Congress slipped into opposition control. It has remained split between the three main parties ever since, although the Institutional Revolutionary Party gained a near majority last summer. Additionally, few significant reforms were approved during the 2000-2006 administration of President Vicente Fox.

Calderón, meanwhile, has managed to push through reforms of the criminal justice system, taxation and the energy sector, but many political observers say those overhauls were inadequate. 

"As a country, we've taken half steps," said Eduardo García, publisher of the online business publication, Sentido Común. "We have a democratic system, but it's very divided."

Those divisions were on display during the 2008 debates to reform the energy sector, one key area in which Brazil and Mexico have taken disparate development approaches. The Mexican reforms allowed for increased private sector participation in the state-run oil concern, Pemex, but failed to address deep-seated problems, such as the dominance of the oil workers' union. They also failed to provide sufficient incentives for outside players to help discover and exploit new petroleum fields, at a time when Mexican production was in decline.

Pemex lacks the technology to exploit deep-water fields in the Gulf of Mexico, which might hold enormous reserves. Meanwhile, Brazil's state-controlled oil company, Petrobras, has been hailed as a world-class company that successfully exploits deep-water reserves.

Pardinas thinks Brazil's management of its petroleum sector could serve as an example for Mexico, where keeping the oil industry in government hands is a pillar of national sovereignty. He also hopes the country can turn itself around like Brazil has over the past two decades.

"Brazil's success is a motive for envy. However, its successes give us hope that history is not destiny and the future is not a mechanical repetition of the present," he wrote.

**David Agren is a freelance journalist in Mexico City. He previously covered government and politics for The News, Mexico City's English-language daily. 

World Politics Review (Estados Unidos)

 


Otras Notas Relacionadas... ( Records 1 to 10 of 6281 )
fecha titulo
22/12/2014 México: El salpicado
29/11/2014 Brasil - Dilma Rousseff: ¿Sabia o traidora?
28/11/2014 A acabar con la corrupción y la impunidad política en México
10/11/2014 Mexico - Tsunami de violencia y corrupción
09/11/2014 Reconstrucción de la captura y muerte de los estudiantes de Iguala
08/11/2014 Mexico - Historia de un fracaso
07/11/2014 La economía del crimen en México
03/11/2014 Mexico - El Estado secuestrado
28/10/2014 Brasil, el mundo de mañana
26/10/2014 México: el grito de Iguala


Otras Notas del Autor
fecha
Título
15/03/2018|
25/06/2010|
02/12/2009|
02/12/2009|

ver + notas
 
Center for the Study of the Presidency
Freedom House