THE COMPARISON BETWEEN THE October 2023 attack on Israel and the Yom Kippur War is reasonable. We still have an obscured perspective on what happened on October 7. But even this partial picture makes it possible to draw a preliminary comparison. Undoubtedly, there is no precedent for such a monumental failure in the history of Israeli intelligence.
The most
striking difference between the two case studies is that in 1973 the system as
a whole did not fail. The failure was personal, on the part of several key
people, who did not perform according to expectations. The events of 2023 point
to a systemic failure at all levels, not personal mistakes. The failure is at
the level of intelligence warning, the military response to the attack, and
even the actions of Israel’s political leadership.
An
Intelligence and Military Failure
In 1973,
the intelligence-gathering system was working well, and Egypt’s war intentions
were known. Thousands of reports from observations along the Suez Canal spoke
of the Egyptian preparations. The wireless transmissions that were issued
testified to preparation for war in the Egyptian army. All this did not
translate into a warning of war, due to the failed performance of some senior
officers in the Israeli Military Intelligence (IMI), who stuck to their
preconceived notions until the last moment.
In 2023,
the failure is systemic. It involves both the level of collection and at the
level of assessment. It relates both to the IMI and the Israel Security Agency
(ISA). It has already become clear that the intelligence collection mechanisms
failed to detect large-scale preparations for an all-out attack from the Gaza
Strip. A massive intelligence system failed to detect the preparatory actions
of the assailing forces.
When the
perceived enemy is Palestinian civilians and when Israel Defense Forces (IDF)
soldiers spend their time guarding settlements and worshipers, instead of
engaging in hard training, the result is catastrophic. On October 7, we
witnessed the operations of an army whose main mission is occupation. Given
what we saw on that day, namely more than 1,000 civilian and military casualties
and approximately 150 kidnapped Israelis, it is not clear how this army will be
able to face the upcoming challenges in this war. The need for the
professionalism and resilience of the IDF, which was there in 1973, continues
to exist.
A
Political Failure
The
comparison between the political leadership of 1973 and 2023 is also
discouraging. Back then, the root of the failure was that the intelligence
information the leadership received from Eli Zeira, the director of IMI, who
was the nation’s most senior intelligence officer, was distorted and false. It
is now understood that the IMI’s assessments were based on the concept of
reassuring the political leadership. Yet, Prime Minister Golda Meir and
Minister of Defense Moshe Dayan were challenged after the war, and were
eventually removed from their positions. However, they acted responsibly.
In
contrast, there is not much to say about Israel’s current political leadership.
It suffices to look at the composition of the Security Cabinet and the first
leaks that have already begun to emanate from it, or at the surge of slander
that members of the governing coalition have begun to heap on the finest of the
IDF’s officers. It is nothing short of a disgrace and a disaster.
This war
has just begun. It is still too early to draw conclusions. But we can examine
the conclusions from the Yom Kippur War and assess their relevance to today.
When Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu talks about revenge, it is
advisable to remember those lessons. The conflict with the Palestinians is long
and bitter. They will not give up their ambition for their state. It is now
time to comprehend the full cost of the continuation of the conflict.
***Dr.
Avner Barnea is research fellow at the National Security Studies Center of the University
of Haifa in Israel. He served as a senior officer in the Israel Security Agency
(ISA). He is the author of We Never Expected That: A Comparative Study of
Failures in National and Business Intelligence (Lexington Books, 2021).
https://intelnews.org/2023/10/11/01-3311/